Hello I recently

Austin

Mame
Messages
162
Reaction score
0
Location
Minnesota
USDA Zone
3
Hello I recently started down the trail of growing bonsai trees, I started in mid october 2012 by diging up some tree seedlings and starting hte process of stratification of some seeds.

it is now mid january and the trident maple seeds have sprouted, the oaks now have leaves and I've managed to kill a number of willow cuttings by over watering them, I found the stage between cutting and treeling to be a difficult one to gauge and as a result they where over watered or moved at a terrible time.

I live in northern Minnesota in planting zone 3..my specific area 2A 2B and 3A converge and it is literally only like that around my home town the rest of the area surrounding my town is all zone 3B. (forgive me if I got the A's and the B's mixed up)

now I did research befor planting or digging up anything on air layering and cuttings and transplanting potting mix and so forth. I came up with these points

Chiken grit, expanded clay and a peat and black dirt mix for potting soil at about 60 inorganic/40 organic that i've personally tested and works well for me

now the issue I need to address is I have plants from outside of my zone that need winter such as Trident Maples, wich off the top of my head are a zone 5-7 plant, I also started some tropicals I know how to deal with them.

Now during my research I discovered a few things plants in the northern environment go into dormancey when night time temps (or emperatures in general) drop below 50 degrees F, the plant then begins to accumulate what is known as "Chill Hours" hours accumulated between the temperatures 32-45 F with between 45-50 counting as a half hour and between 32-(I thought it was 0) counting as a half hour, anyhting below that does not count and anything spent at 60 or great counts as a negative to your chill hour accumulation. That is what I grasped from reading on the internet most articles simply stated that 32-45 was when the plant does its "dormancy thing" and moves into post dormancy or starts waking however I found this near the end of my research on chill hours

The Utah Model says that
1 hour of chill below 34 F. is worth nothing
1 hour at between 35 and 36 F. gets 1/2 a chill hour
1 chill hour is given at 37 to 48 F.
49 to 54 F. gets only 1/2 a chill hour
55 to 60 F. get no chill hours
Above 60 is all negative chill …..eeekk!!!

dunno if it's credible but seems smart

after being armed with that information I started to look for average chill hour maps, much like hte planting zone maps they show some interesting data.

http://raintreenursery.com/skin/common_files/pages/en/images/chill-unit-map3.gif

in my area we get between 1200-1800 chill hour annually wich equates to roughly 73 days, for a state that sees almost five months of snow to think that only 73 days or less of it are around 32-45 degrees, then I thought "well gee we only get about a month of that in the spring and a month of that in the fall" the rest of the time we are hovering between -20 and +20. My idea is to build a wall unit with air in and air out fans and some mild duct work and a thermostat to control the fans, get to warm in the case intake fan kicks on blowing in cool outside air, case gets too cold the gate for air intake closes and the exhaust fan kicks on sucking out cold air and replacing it with warmer air that will inevitably be sucked in thru cracks in the glass or plexy glass face. I know how to construct and wire this and also have all the parts...locating them will prove interesting however.

Does anyone have anything to say on this idea befor I begin building it? is it a huge mistake? has anyone ever done something similar? (I know people have wintered plants in refrigerators, and I also tryed that with a few plants my self this year successfully) and how do you suggest I winter my naturally occurring specimens?

but all in all this will be quite a year and I may have some seedlings for sale or trade in a few months (they would not be able to ship of coarse until erly October)

soo do I seem to have my stuff together or did I just go out and make a huge mistake?

if you read all of this, your a soldier in my book.

Austin
 
That is a lot to take in for me to give you any honest opinion at this time but I will read that a few more times and possibly tell you to pm me for a phone number - my ld is free so iI can call you as well. You really need to update and detail your profile as well to show actual location. No offense but many more will advise if they have a better idea based on your profile.
 
Last edited:
You say you dug up your trident seedlings. Does that mean that they were growing naturally in your area? Are there other full grown trident maples in the area where you found the seedlings?

Edit - sorry, I just realized I mis-read that. let me fix my post now..

In the meatime, for more food-for-thought, check out this article about an Alaskan bonsai-er: Alaskan Bonsai Winter Care
 
Last edited:
Actually, I think if you're around 3B or even 2A and have snow five months out of the year, the Alaska Winter Care solution may be the simplest way to go...
 
I actually Pulled up 10 tree seedling I found in the woods 3 pines four oaks nad some others one was a birch then wintered them in my fridge at 32 degrees for a month, then planted them in a pot, and 50% of them lived (good for ripping them out of the ground I thought)

I will review the alaska method after work today

but according to the data this wintering case should work, my intention was to shorten my winter period for my trees to 3 months (considering 2 months worked) that way I will have fall coulor in november and spring by erly march verses the standard bemidji MN winter (area code 56601) october- beginning of march is our winter time.

also I have recently found an infestation of spider mites that whiped out my two blueberry bushes I've had growing inside sense october, they are very responsive to light and cold so they happen to be an awesome indicator as to what seasonal weather the other plants are experianceing.

any and all input is welcome this is an experiment for me and I find it quite interesting and thus far the results are positive
 
also updated my profile and will upload some pictures once I find my usb hook up for my camera
 
You need to slow down and reach out to a local club. You're making some broad assumptions as well as soil that is going to kill you trees.

"Chiken grit, expanded clay and a peat and black dirt mix for potting soil at about 60 inorganic/40 organic that i've personally tested and works well for me"

This is a recipe for disaster for just about any tree. Unless you've had success with it for more than a year or so, don't count it as a success. A succesful bonsai soil is one that doesn't turn to mush over time and can keep its structure for years.

You insight into winter dormancy is good, but you're trying to push too much precise math into it. Dormancy is NOT a simple. It can depend on species, very much on location and even the location with in that location. What works in a book becomes extremely sketchy in real life. I've overwintered temperate zone trees for going on 20 years now. No winter is the same or realibly fits a neat pattern of filling chilling hours for trees. You can't tell precisely when a tree passes its hour limit, nor if the winter cold has killed it (and trident maples need a lot of protection in a Minnesota winter).

For bonsai specific take on overwintering read the articles below. They will take some of the mystery out of the process
http://www.evergreengardenworks.com/overwint.htm

Particularly the section on "Serious Freeze Protection in Cold Areas"

http://www.evergreengardenworks.com/dormancy.htm
 
I know that Crust has built a winter survival shelter for his plants he's in your neck of the woods. He has posted in the thread below, take a look and that'll give you some food for thought. But I believe that Crust has given up on some species, as they are just too hard to grow up there. I think Trident was one of these...
Maybe he will see this and chime in...
good luck, and welcome.

http://bonsainut.com/forums/showthread.php?9427-Winter-setup-for-Minnesota

BTW, I have a cold greenhouse, in which I use a combination of heat mats/thermostats with probes, and a heater/cooler setup that includes a fan to spread the heat, and a electric louver setup with a venting fan on the opposite side attached to a thermostat. If you want info on what I use or pictures, I'll be happy to send that along. Just know that I'm in zone 5, not zone 3.
 
Last edited:
Tahnks for your input Judy I'll review the links hopefully this evening. I do realise that it is not a math formula and plants are genetically used to random weather patterns, I was hoping this Wintering case would more accurately emulate a natural environment by using cool outside air as there would be an amount of random air movement determined by the temp inside and ouside of the case.

as this is my first year I'm simply testing variables to see what works and what doesn't, I have a hard time just taking someones word on a lot of topics so seeing for myself has allways been the best for me.

and honestly that potting mix I mentioned is mainly for my willows and pines and has worked well thus far, not saying it's solid but it's worked. Also from my reading a 70/30 mix or even 80/20 I hear is best (wich I will use on some seedlings I've ordered from the arbor day foundation that should arrive in two months time from now)

also I've had the most success with nothing but peat and black dirt 50/50 (I know its a sin but it's working for me at the moment) and there again it's a variable test for my own experiance.

I know I do not have the answers or experience so I have turned to this forum.

thanks for your help

Edit: I also have not been able to locate a bonsai group in my area
 
There is at least one Minnesotan here. I think you've been given a link to his posts.

When there aint no group, sometimes you gotta make friends retail.
 
Also I appoligise for the erratic posts I'm in an out of the office all day and I having ADHD severely have a tendency to not organize things well or cover all variables
 
You say you dug up your trident seedlings. Does that mean that they were growing naturally in your area? Are there other full grown trident maples in the area where you found the seedlings?

Edit - sorry, I just realized I mis-read that. let me fix my post now..

In the meatime, for more food-for-thought, check out this article about an Alaskan bonsai-er: Alaskan Bonsai Winter Care

that is actually almost the exact idea I planned on using for my first winter only I would be using preen to cover the pots and then covering the tops with sawdust (being I have a wood factory not shop factory in my back yard) we built a road thru a swamp with nothing but sawdust works awesome as an insulator and actually allows a lot of moisture to drain to the bottom depending on the size of the sawdust particles. Any thoughts on the sawdust idea?
 
Pine bark mulch--the shredded kind not the nuggets. Sawdust compacts and stay far too soggy over a period of months.
 
Pine bark mulch--the shredded kind not the nuggets. Sawdust compacts and stay far too soggy over a period of months.

I would agree with you on that but as I've been in the wood shop sense I was 8 years old (family owned business) there are some "shreddings" that are more like your pine bark wich is what would be used, but yes definately not the fine particles, as I stated I built a road out of the fine sawdust almost half a mile long.

any suggestions on getting trees with leaves out of dirt and into bonsai soil at the wrong time of the year?
 
as this is my first year I'm simply testing variables to see what works and what doesn't, I have a hard time just taking someones word on a lot of topics so seeing for myself has allways been the best for me.

I know I do not have the answers or experience so I have turned to this forum.

Just so you know and I am certain this will give you even "more" energy to push on forward. I am from a Scientific background and my Wife is an Enviornmental Engineer. I only persued a BA but she of course had to get a Masters...
All that being said - She has been showing me Bonsai for several years now and after TWO years of playing about on my own I will start my own projects this Spring. If there is not anyone nearby that cannot help(here a decent ANYTHING bonsai is simply to far away) I am certain you will find this "Bunch Of B-Nuts" to be some of the nicest people around :D I myself would be willing to let you call me or I could call you as my long distance is free. If need be feel free to PM me :cool:
 
Last edited:
here is what I've kept alive sense october 7'th
I also found an infestation of spider mites on some blue berries I had kept inside all winter...attempted to treat them and they migrated to the other plants but at least I know why the blueberries never took off

this is an example of the damage done by the mites in two days (so of the burn is from pestisicide)

Befor : http://img827.imageshack.us/img827/551/willowcuttingbeformites.jpg

After : http://img213.imageshack.us/img213/8431/closeup1a.jpg
http://img689.imageshack.us/img689/1588/closeupza.jpg

weeping willow cutting taken in October

my oaks

Befor : http://img811.imageshack.us/img811/2083/oak1beformites1.jpg

2 http://imageshack.us/f/40/oak2beformites.jpg/


After : http://img20.imageshack.us/img20/4062/oak1aftermites2.jpg
http://img72.imageshack.us/img72/7633/oak1aftermites.jpg


http://img607.imageshack.us/img607/2522/oak2t.jpg
http://imageshack.us/a/img593/8099/spidermites2.jpg

I have no idea what this guy is http://img809.imageshack.us/img809/6937/spidermites1.jpg
but he had minimal mite damage and lots of chemical burn...didn't read the bottle well be for using the chemical.

my happy indoor pine been growing sense october http://imageshack.us/a/img825/3050/pine.jpg indoors

http://img547.imageshack.us/img547/1233/willowcutting1aftermite.jpg and my first willow cutting that took this fall

now if you look do you think you can tell me if it was mite or scale damage? I saw some webbing near affected plants leaf tips but not much I know when I shake the tree over papaer I get pepperish looking dots on the paper, I also washed the leaves befor taking the After pictures.
 

Attachments

  • closeup1.jpg
    closeup1.jpg
    188.4 KB · Views: 11
You need to slow down and reach out to a local club. You're making some broad assumptions as well as soil that is going to kill you trees.

"Chiken grit, expanded clay and a peat and black dirt mix for potting soil at about 60 inorganic/40 organic that i've personally tested and works well for me"

This is a recipe for disaster for just about any tree. Unless you've had success with it for more than a year or so, don't count it as a success. A succesful bonsai soil is one that doesn't turn to mush over time and can keep its structure for years.

You insight into winter dormancy is good, but you're trying to push too much precise math into it. Dormancy is NOT a simple. It can depend on species, very much on location and even the location with in that location. What works in a book becomes extremely sketchy in real life. I've overwintered temperate zone trees for going on 20 years now. No winter is the same or realibly fits a neat pattern of filling chilling hours for trees. You can't tell precisely when a tree passes its hour limit, nor if the winter cold has killed it (and trident maples need a lot of protection in a Minnesota winter).

For bonsai specific take on overwintering read the articles below. They will take some of the mystery out of the process
http://www.evergreengardenworks.com/overwint.htm

Particularly the section on "Serious Freeze Protection in Cold Areas"

http://www.evergreengardenworks.com/dormancy.htm

I read this article after posting pictures tonight it fall right in along with all the other research I've done, except he shortend it to 1000 hours of chill time instead of my intended and tested 1500, the article even talked about refrigerating them like I did.
 
Pine bark mulch--the shredded kind not the nuggets. Sawdust compacts and stay far too soggy over a period of months.

The local tractor supply places have Pine horse bedding(we get ours at AGWAY) and the type we use is a course curl no dust. We have been using it for quite a few years as it is inexpensive and pure Pine chip with no chemicals. Also it is ALWAYS in stock :)
 
Hey Austin, could you try posting your photos on the thread instead of an off site host? I think you'll get more replies.
 
lol it didn't want ot upload them to the site it just sat and loaded until my computer froze

Edit: I guess the pic uploaded but my computer still froze...
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom