AaronThomas
Omono
I many have digressed a bit....
You have to push it to the limit, otherwise we never get to that next level all the professionals talk about.I believe modern bonsai thinking is only one insult per year?
Hmmm... I think dwarf is on the shitlist, too.You can't say that anymore. Little tree.
Never took it as one. The theme is "insults" so I frivolously went with the word.Not an insult at all. Just seems like you've been feeling frivolous lately, which isn't bad at all we probably all need a little levity right now.
Whilst the term most commonly referred to a little person, it also refers to a little thing...You can't say that anymore. Little tree.
You need to let that trunk thicken up...............
It will if you show it your grow bedYou need to let that trunk thicken up...............
It depends on who you are listening to, and how horrible the insults discussed. I have found that the time of year you throw and insult at a tree is more important than the nature of the insult. Near 60yrs experience insulting trees at the wrong time of year.I believe modern bonsai thinking is only one insult per year?
There are two forms of bonsai out there that have for years had a built in escape clause allowing the developer to claim the tree is a wonderful bonsai without demonstrating any beauty at all: First the Literati: only important to be skinny and uninteresting and second: The ubiquitious American Bonsai where critique is not allowed. It is after all an American bonsai not definable by Japanese standards, or anyone else's for that matter. It really becomes interesting and madening, when both are involved.Bonsai Club talk
“Man, I’m all for literati, but that’s basically just a sapling.”
”I know what you mean. I get all excited about seeing some slender, curvaceous forms, but that right there is nothin’ but a stick in a pot!”
“Still, rather that than that fatty. I just can’t tell where the nebari ends and the trunk begins...”
“Woah! Check out Acer over there, he’s got his roots right over that rock.”
”You know, I’m glad for him. He’s always trying to expose his roots and finally he got an anchor point.”
“Yea but everyone’s had a turn on that rock. I bet she doesn't even know his cultivar...”
Or, is he just playing the straight faced genius?This thread...
View attachment 290669
Well there we go. Two styles which mirror the human equivalent, perhaps?There are two forms of bonsai out there that have for years had a built in escape clause allowing the developer to claim the tree is a wonderful bonsai without demonstrating any beauty at all: First the Literati: only important to be skinny and uninteresting and second: The ubiquitious American Bonsai where critique is not allowed. It is after all an American bonsai not definable by Japanese standards, or anyone else's for that matter. It really becomes interesting and madening, when both are involved.