Suggestions on Styling Trident Maple

Messages
154
Reaction score
192
Location
Central Kentucky
USDA Zone
6b
I’m not sure where to go with this one. When it arrived to me last year, it was root bound—discovered after I wired it. Not sure what I was going for, but it needed repotting more than anything else and has been left alone to recover.

This year I’d like to do something with it. Any tips on styling?

EDIT: Originally made a post about this and accidentally identifying this as a JM. Have requested the former post be removed. Sorry for duplicate posts/confusion.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_8358.jpg
    IMG_8358.jpg
    235.6 KB · Views: 45
  • IMG_8359.jpg
    IMG_8359.jpg
    208.9 KB · Views: 36
  • IMG_8360.jpg
    IMG_8360.jpg
    180.1 KB · Views: 30
  • IMG_8361.jpg
    IMG_8361.jpg
    219.7 KB · Views: 28
Last edited:
If you could take the pictures from lower, like straight across the pot, it'll make advice easier. Looks to me like #1 is your front, and I'd look at a double trunk at this point.
I agree with #1 being the front. I was hesitant to lop off the second trunk just in case this were an option. Glad I held off.

I'll take a few more photos now.
 
Other angles.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_8366.jpg
    IMG_8366.jpg
    195.3 KB · Views: 25
  • IMG_8364.jpg
    IMG_8364.jpg
    212 KB · Views: 18
  • IMG_8363.jpg
    IMG_8363.jpg
    203.7 KB · Views: 18
  • IMG_8368.jpg
    IMG_8368.jpg
    246.9 KB · Views: 34
I would think about putting it in a wider container and working the root structure as soon as possible. The roots take a long time to develop, so best start that early on. Maybe think about the board under the tree technique. The base has a nice shape, and where the second trunk come out also has a nice shape, but you’ll have to cut it down to get some taper and movement in both the main and secondary trunk.
 
I would think about putting it in a wider container and working the root structure as soon as possible. The roots take a long time to develop, so best start that early on. Maybe think about the board under the tree technique. The base has a nice shape, and where the second trunk come out also has a nice shape, but you’ll have to cut it down to get some taper and movement in both the main and secondary trunk.
So no chopping this year? You'd recommend repotting and boarding?

Also, the nabari above the soil doesn't really connect to the roots below. I was barely able to fit the tree in this pot due to the depth of the nabari beneath the nabari, if that makes sense. It looks like two layers thick set of nabari atop each other. Maybe someone air layered this in the past and something didn't work out? The nabari below the trunk is still very much alive, though 'cosmetic'.

I'm not sure about this one.
 
I would think about putting it in a wider container and working the root structure as soon as possible. The roots take a long time to develop, so best start that early on. Maybe think about the board under the tree technique. The base has a nice shape, and where the second trunk come out also has a nice shape, but you’ll have to cut it down to get some taper and movement in both the main and secondary trunk.
Here is a really bad drawing of what I’m talking about.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_8369.jpeg
    IMG_8369.jpeg
    184.4 KB · Views: 31
Tridents do handle root work really well, so you should think about cutting off the old underneath roots. Those happen when nurseries up pot the tree and it grows new roots at the surface. If the top set of roots is strong, no reason you will have a problem getting rid of the lower section. You could also do a chop at the same time on one of the trunks. I’d probably do the rootwork get it on a board, maybe even do some root grafting while you’re in there and chop down the secondary trunk, just don’t go too far down, wait to see what old buds pop on it before you decide where to take it.
 
Sounds like a plan. I'll need to look into root grafting. Thanks for the insight, this helps give me some direction.

Now to find a bonsai pot large enough... This was the largest I could find locally.

Thanks again!
 
Sounds like a plan. I'll need to look into root grafting. Thanks for the insight, this helps give me some direction.

Now to find a bonsai pot large enough... This was the largest I could find locally.

Thanks again!
Anderson flats work great as well as self built grow boxes if you don’t want to spend a pile of money on an actual pot.
 
Tridents do handle root work really well, so you should think about cutting off the old underneath roots. Those happen when nurseries up pot the tree and it grows new roots at the surface. If the top set of roots is strong, no reason you will have a problem getting rid of the lower section. You could also do a chop at the same time on one of the trunks. I’d probably do the rootwork get it on a board,
Agree totally.
Someone has planted this tree in the ground but planted a bit too deep. Tridents almost always grow new roots right at ground level. I used this to grow tridents commercially for a while - no need for initial root work, just slap the trunk deep in the grow bed, leave for 2-3 years. Success rate was around 70% good new roots. Then dig and cut the old roots leaving a flat set of new roots and a flared trunk. I've since developed another technique that gives even better results.
Point is, be careful when planting tridents in the ground. Don't put roots too deep if you want to keep those roots.

No problem cutting the lower roots completely. Tridents have no problem with up to 90% root reduction. I usually also cut the lateral roots much shorter on the initial root prune. New roots almost always develop from the cut ends so if you want the roots to ramify closer to the trunk that's where you need to chop them. I typically cut roots around 1 trunk diameter long. With hard root prune like this I often get new roots developing which could save the problem of grafting new roots.
Make sure the roots are totally covered with soil after potting up. The ends MUST not dry out if they are to develop new roots. Cover with enough soil so the entire nebari is covered for the first summer. Plenty of time to show the roots after new roots are growing strong.

I know planting on boards is a popular thing now but I don't find planting on boards helpful. Once deeper roots are cut they don't tend to grow again. Because tridents rely on lateral surface roots they will almost always develop in preference to deep roots so the board is redundant. During board planting trials I noted that any small roots that are missed can thicken under the trunk and lift the nebari off the board anyway.

Chopping the trunks:
Your biggest problem is no taper in either trunk. It will take a few years but chopping low is the only way I know to rectify lack of taper. First trunk chop is typically less than 1/3 planned height of your bonsai so If you have a size in mind that will help make decisions.
Second problem is a cluster of branches on the main trunk around the height of the second trunk. This is common but quickly leads to local swelling and inverse taper. I suspect the trunk already has that happening which means chopping below there is probably the best option.

It's usually better to chop to a strong side branch. Hard to tell with the odd photo angles whether there's any useful existing branches but it appears there's one strong branch with a slight upward angle among that cluster. It's not clear whether that one is upright enough to become the continuation of the trunk or if it emerges in an appropriate spot to use the 2nd trunk as a twin trunk. I'd consider that branch as possible new section of trunk first with a sloping cut behind the branch to help with trunk taper.
If that branch is no good I'd chop just below the cluster of branches and cross fingers.
In either case, also chop the 2nd trunk lower too - probably down to the first node on it.
 
Back
Top Bottom