Congrats on your program, however, I think you are going to wish you used the cutting method in the long run. It takes longer for them to develop but the results are better. Good luck...looking forward to see these develop.
You are ahead of the game compare to mine.My indoor trees show compact growth, enthusiastic adventitious buds, and strong extension of mature needles:
View attachment 196278
My outdoor trees show extending, juvenile growth and a slower, less vigorous extension of mature needles:
View attachment 196279
Our weather has been a bit mixed. Warm and sunny days have occurred, but overnight lows have dipped into the mid-40s for a while.
My suggestion would be to consider overwatering, on the basis that the needles are showing signs of yellowing from the base out and there is pronounced needle browning and drop in the basal area. This is common to young pines without mature root formation. Particularly as the cooler, damper weather begins and they require less than earlier in the season. Also i do not observe any banding that might indicate another common fungal issue of needlecast.One tray has turned an off color. From my reading this is either fungal or dehydration. (I’m guessing fungal)
View attachment 216022
All other trays appear normal.
That's a real good move. One little trick that i have used is to wire chopsticks or wooden feet on the bottom of the anderson flat before use! This gives them some airflow when using the flats for seed trays. When i use them for larger trees i nest one in the other. The lower one has holes drilled in the sides all around the outer circumference about 1/2 inch up from the bottom. This allows the inner tray to rest up higher drain freely and the bottom tray has side holes to allow evaporation and gas exchange. I use a 1/4 inch bit for holes in the plastic sides of the lower tray. This collected Shimpaku is potted up in the fashion described above. The third little trick i use is to always try to set Anderson flats on a porous surface such as gravel, large wood chips or slatted bench surface.I’ve propped up all of my Anderson flats to ensure better air circulation underneath them.