The Any Maple, Progressive~Progressive Bonsai Contest

Not up to me, but since the forum containes so many sub forums for species I figured it would be natural to post them in the maple section. I guess I supposed wrong huh.....but I see people post trees all willie nilly so its par. People talk about collected trees in general all the time and we have a collected sub forum and everything.

People get mad when noobies ask quetions that have been chewed on numerous times like soil, but they are not all in the soil subforum. If someone new comes here and wants to learn about soil, they will miss more than half the threads. Moderation takes time...and no one wants to be a baby sitter....
Had this thread about the contest been posted in Maples, perhaps people would have followed suit.. As is, I imagine most people posted there trees in "general" so far for the same reason you posted the contest thread here- visibility. More people visit General than any others... I agree this would be a better fit in Maples and easier to find there... Perhaps Bnut can love them? It is only a couple threads so far, right?
 
Interesting, I just hit new posts, and get all posts in all the forums. Que sera, sera.
 
So.....I'll keep posting in the "general" forum...then...I guess....until somebody says different:p
 
If you were looking for info on maples where would you look?

There is no right answer, just a people observation.

These were the original rules from the first thread. I did not copy them to the next thread progressive~progressive....My bad.


"The challenge will take place over a year and there are not many rules.
The Rules
1. This contest is for any Acer species. From tridents to palmatums and Field Maples.

2. Tree can be bought from any store. A bonsai store is preferable. No receipt will be needed.

3. Trunk minimum of three inches at 1 inch above soil. There is no wiggle room. 3 inches! There is no limit on price. In fact I implore you to spend a goodly sum of money to make this a bonafied BONSAI contest.

4. No height limit.

5. Tree must be potted in exhibit container. No rule on container but should be aesthetically pleasing. Moss optional.

6. Tree can have been purchased in the calendar year of 2014 till March 14, 2016. Of course this is a progression contest and the more pictures the better.

7. You opening post will show a before picture. It should be posted in the "maple" section. If the tree was bought in 2014 then it still has to have a before picture. This will also help those that do not take pictures of their trees to be more mindful the next time. (Any picture will do as long as "good work" from whatever pictures is posted takes place over the next twelve months.)

8. Pictures of work to be posted monthly in your contest thread which will have many comments in it, some of them derogatory, and some respectful, probably arguments, but everyone will benefit.

9. The contest will end March 15, 2016 and finished photos will be submitted by March 25, 2016. Winner to be announced April 1, 2016. The Judge, ( and it will be a good one, one that everyone in the bonsai community is familiar with) will receive the finished photos and the before shot in an email and it will be a blind judging.

During the five days of the judging, a thread will be started with a poll for each tree and there will be an opportunity for a "peoples" choice (forum) also."
 
Had this thread about the contest been posted in Maples, perhaps people would have followed suit.. As is, I imagine most people posted there trees in "general" so far for the same reason you posted the contest thread here- visibility. More people visit General than any others... I agree this would be a better fit in Maples and easier to find there... Perhaps Bnut can love them? It is only a couple threads so far, right?
Lmao, obviously the post above was supposed to read "perhaps Bnut can MOVE them", not love them...
 
Interesting, I just hit new posts, and get all posts in all the forums. Que sera, sera.
Yeah, I think most people do that sometimes, but the general forum still gets most the traffic.
 
hmmm.... hard to argue with that logic.
I don't see the need to argue at all smoke. That is certainly not why I come here... Let's just ask Bnut to move them! I will send him a message about mine now...
 
I am wondering what the entry date cutoff is? I looked thru the rules in post #84, and don't see one. Just super busy right now, for another week after this one... But I'll try if it's next week.
 
I am wondering what the entry date cutoff is? I looked thru the rules in post #84, and don't see one. Just super busy right now, for another week after this one... But I'll try if it's next week.
I'm curious too, since I don't have my trees at the new house yet and it's hard to get pictures.
 
Is this contest still on?
------->
The contest will end March 15, 2016 and finished photos will be submitted by March 25, 2016. Winner to be announced April 1, 2016. Nothing significant about that date. But wait..there's more. The contest will continue into the next year. Same ending date. But some of those people that have those damn short growing seasons and did not really get the growth on those branches they wanted will get a second chance the following year. Possibly same judge or a new one, I have several bonafied people I can go to on this trust me. progressive~progressive could go on for years till that damn tree is finally a bonsai even if it takes ten years!!!!! I'm willing to go the distance if you guys are.

Good question. If photos need to be submitted, where to?
------->
Start a thread for your tree and call it something creative, but put something in the title that denotes you have thrown your hat in the ring.
 
Well I have kept up my posts in the thread, but not sure if there needs to be an official entry photo, if indeed this contest still exists.
 
I haven't got a clue what's going on here. There's a contest but I don't see any entries. Don't even know if I have missed or are missing something..... ? :confused:
 
Back
Top Bottom