What was the best bonsai/tree related advice you have been given?

Eric Group

Masterpiece
Messages
4,555
Reaction score
4,882
Location
Columbia, SC
One liners or ideas that take some explaining... One best or multiple good ones? Just thought it might be cool to compile a thread full of valuable nuggets of wisdom we can all use!

I will start us off with a few nuggets of wisdom I have been given:

One regarding soil composition- I asked my friend what he thought of the soil debates we have had on here in recent years and he told me something a "master" had once told him (Kimura . Think is who he credited with this one): "you can grow a tree in marbles if you care for it properly"! Thought that one was funny because it is true basically... Proper watering and feeding and you can grow a pretty happy tree in most anything! This is why the discussion always comes up with so many varying view points because many people have success with many different substrates. He also gave me some pointers on oxygen exchange and how the act of watering your trees FULLY and Heavily until to he water runs out of the bottom of your pots is not just an exercise in adding water, but is also- and perhaps more importantly- exchanging oxygen! Forcing out the old "stake" air in the roots, and replacing it with fresh air. This discourages fungal growth and encourages root growth... This is why- even if a tree is perhaps not really dry- it is important to water your trees often, and speaks to why we should get the best results from porous, fast draining soil.

A piece of advice regarding general plant care that my mother was once given by a "master gardener": you don't truly know a plant until you have killed it at least three times"... Kind of makes you feel better about losing a tree but teaches a valuable lesson too- the death of that tree/ plant wasn't a TOTAL loss if you learned something from it that might help you keep one from dying in the future.

I have been given some solid wiring advice recently as well- John taught me how to use two sets of pliers to bend the wire instead of using your fingers to bend the branch and wire... And Arhtur Juror gave me some advice on how to select the correct gauge of wire to bend a specific branch by testing a small section of it by pressing it against the branch- if it bends the branch, it is strong enough (obviously) if the wire bends is read of the branch, get some bigger wire!

Obviously it is hard to pick just one, so nobody is saying you have to! I don't care if the source is Kimura, or Joe across the street from you or if the source is... YOU... Just drop some knowledge on us!!
 
1)join a club to learn more about what works in your area.
2)buy better stock to save time
3)be patient with every tree.
 
Mine has to do with wiring, something I struggled with longer than I should have.

when positioning a smaller branch from the main one it is attached to. Lay the smaller branch
flat against the main branch for about a half inch before flaring it out to where you want it. That way it takes the opportunity of the smaller branch parting at the connecting crotch .learned at a pine workshop of larry Jackel's.
 
To enjoy your bonsai even when a branch is a bit out of shape or unruly for awhile before it finally fills out or serves it's purpose.
 
Best Advice

Don't force the tree to be what you want it to be. Listen to it tell you what it wants to be.
 
Research winter care...before you make your purchase. Research and back up your findings with several sources. Make sure your capable of providing such needs before the purchase or before winter approaches.
 
Don't listen to advice via the internet...

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You win!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Irony

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You win!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

He said, ironically, on the internet.
 
Cull Bull.

Sorce
 
Mine has to do with wiring, something I struggled with longer than I should have.

when positioning a smaller branch from the main one it is attached to. Lay the smaller branch
flat against the main branch for about a half inch before flaring it out to where you want it. That way it takes the opportunity of the smaller branch parting at the connecting crotch .learned at a pine workshop of larry Jackel's.

I kind of see what you are saying here, but I am having trouble visualizing it... Do you mean lay it flat against the larger one in the sense of trying to "fuse" them together, or is this just a temporary thing... Seems like you wouldn't get the best shape in the end doing it this way, and if you are creating the separation later you would still have the same potential to cause a split at the crotch of the branches then...? Not doubting the technique, I appreciate you sharing, just a little confused I guess... Any elaboration you can provide to clarify this one for me?
 
On BSG, Chat section - I think Matsu Bonsai found out that on our side Lingnan [ Grow and Clip ] was mostly used, very little wiring.
He said I was lazy.

Had me laughing for days.:):):)

As one of those folk presently growing trees in marbles, from 3 mm to 15 mm with just compost as the organic, I would agree with, was it Kimura.
In fact a long term growing situation with only 3 mm glass marbles / beads is under way [ and compost ].
Good Day
Anthony
 
Last edited:
My take on the wiring of secondary branches:

I learned this at Boon's: the secondary branches should come off the primary branch at at 45 degree angle (and even closer together at the ends) rather than being splayed out at 90 degree angles.

This helps to keep the branches, when viewed from above, in a triangular shape rather than a circular shape. And it tends to make for denser pads of foliage.
 
I believe it goes"Bonsai need have strong root Danielsan"
 
Bonsai is not a race. Be patient, do the work appropriate for the season, and let your plants grow.
 
Every bonsai boy or girl, who stays in the hobby.

Isn't going anywhere, and is sure they're going to live forever.
 
When evaluating potential material, the only things that really matter are the nebari and lower trunk...the rest will most likely be removed and regrown.
 
Advice

You don't "grow" a bonsai, you "reduce" to a bonsai.

Sorry, don't know where I heard that.

CW
 
Back
Top Bottom