Dav4
Drop Branch Murphy
- Messages
- 13,402
- Reaction score
- 31,701
- USDA Zone
- 6a
Would it look better sitting in the saddle pocket, lower on the left?
I though about setting the trunk there, but decided that this tall, funky stone should have roots crawling along most of it... so the tree sits higher up.Would it look better sitting in the saddle pocket, lower on the left?
I actually started a trident on this stone 4 years ago with the stone laying flat.... killed the trident last spring hard pruning the trunk and rethought the stone's position. The pictures really don't do it justice as it's so 3 dimensional and laying it flat makes it less so. Any way, it's staying upright for now... or at least until I kill the tree.I'd use the saddle pocket for moss growth....running underneath the rock bridges that make the pocket holes.
My first inclination was to use the rock flat out like shown in the first photo. Roots would hang down similar to the rock connectors. I visualized it as a rock where time, rain, wind...elements of nature...wore the ground away creating that hollow area below the roots. In the process the roots became exposed....and moss like growth would invade the cavity area below making the roots stand out nicely.
The tree...and you....will do just fine. The upright is much more majestic. I think my flat version sort of, maybe, just sits there like cooled lava lost in a field with a tree stuck to it. Not to exciting.I actually started a trident on this stone 4 years ago with the stone laying flat.... killed the trident last spring hard pruning the trunk and rethought the stone's position. The pictures really don't do it justice as it's so 3 dimensional and laying it flat makes it less so. Any way, it's staying upright for now... or at least until I kill the tree.
Dave, this is looking great!So, over the weekend, I rednecked the heck out of this one! My two approach graphs have taken and have started to push new growth. I cleaned up the top and performed another approach graft, which will hopefully become the new apex. More twine, brick, wood and stone are being used to wedge Everything in the pot and keep the roots pushed up against the stone for another few months.
View attachment 284175View attachment 284176View attachment 284177View attachment 284178View attachment 284179View attachment 284180View attachment 284181
You and me have nothing to hide here at the nuthouse, buddy! The haters are gonna hate, and I say let them… If they stick around long enough, they might actually learn something .Dave, this is looking great!
but, I gotta warn ya, when you start doing “real bonsai” here, the haters will come after ya!
Thanks for the tip, and I may try it in the future. With this one, I have embraced the scarring that is apparent from previous years work. I suspect the scars will disappear in time, but I also think they add a little bit of character to the gnarly appearance of the tree.@Dav4 I used friction tape and I'd recommend it for binding the roots if you want to try next time. The tape was easy for me to remove. Much of it actually broke down. I like that it leaves no scarring.
The tree looks very clingy.