Should I dig up my boxwood?

Vin said:
If I may add, do not, I repeat do not remove any of the foliage down low. Save it for when you get it to the height you want once it's in a pot. Boxwood never seem to back bud where you want them to. One of the four I have is going to require grafting to get any foliage down low. I'm just waiting for some of the surrounding new branches to get a little longer before I do some approach grafting.
Click to expand...
Understood. Wasn't planning on it.

So, my plan would then be to cut this back substantially, leaving plenty of trunk length and low branches to allow for future design and back budding (hopefully). I would then dig it up ensuring that I start my dig at least 16" away from the trunk. I believe the rule for digging is 8x the diameter of the trunk, but that would be something like 32" and I don't have that kind of room for such a large diameter root ball. I will then repot in a standard bonsai substrate, probably in a wooden box made up of 2x6's.

Sound plan?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Vin
At 7:17 and this is great Colin.

Sorce
 
readc said:
Understood. Wasn't planning on it.

So, my plan would then be to cut this back substantially, leaving plenty of trunk length and low branches to allow for future design and back budding (hopefully). I would then dig it up ensuring that I start my dig at least 16" away from the trunk. I believe the rule for digging is 8x the diameter of the trunk, but that would be something like 32" and I don't have that kind of room for such a large diameter root ball. I will then repot in a standard bonsai substrate, probably in a wooden box made up of 2x6's.

Sound plan?
Click to expand...
What Larry said in the video Colin posted about the nebari should be taken into account. So, maybe start at 16" and when you discover the nebari adjust it down accordingly. It's like a Cracker Jack, until you get to the prize it's just a guessing game.
 
Great looking trunk, flare at the base.
Nice strong looking thing, hope the strength is continued to be conveyed in its future design.
Good luck with how this goes, im curious to see it in the future.
 
Vin said:
What Larry said in the video Colin posted about the nebari should be taken into account. So, maybe start at 16" and when you discover the nebari adjust it down accordingly. It's like a Cracker Jack, until you get to the prize it's just a guessing game.
Click to expand...

Question for you or anyone, I want to go ahead and have a grow box made. Is it possible to know the size of the grow box I should make without having dug the tree? I was thinking 2'x 2' would be safe. This way, I can dig, root prune and put it straight in the box.
 
readc said:
Question for you or anyone, I want to go ahead and have a grow box made. Is it possible to know the size of the grow box I should make without having dug the tree? I was thinking 2'x 2' would be safe. This way, I can dig, root prune and put it straight in the box.
Click to expand...
Based on the tree size 2' x 2' would seem to be about right. The issue I think you're going to have is the depth. I would have a large nursery pot standing by just in case. I'm going to be honest with you (others may disagree), putting a Boxwood of that size in a grow box isn't going to accomplish much. They grow/bulk up really slow and all this tree needs is for the soil to be cleaned from the roots and put in a pot with bonsai soil so you can start the root reduction process. Of all the boxwoods I've collected none went into a grow box and they all are doing fine. The only one I've ever lost was a large one I purchased from a nursery that I tried to reduce to quickly without balancing the roots. https://www.bonsainut.com/threads/in-memoriam-for-those-trees-we-lost-in-2014.18178/#post-244962
 
Vin said:
Based on the tree size 2' x 2' would seem to be about right. The issue I think you're going to have is the depth. I would have a large nursery pot standing by just in case. I'm going to be honest with you (others may disagree), putting a Boxwood of that size in a grow box isn't going to accomplish much. They grow/bulk up really slow and all this tree needs is for the soil to be cleaned from the roots and put in a pot with bonsai soil so you can start the root reduction process. Of all the boxwoods I've collected none went into a grow box and they all are doing fine. The only one I've ever lost was a large one I purchased from a nursery that I tried to reduce to quickly without balancing the roots. https://www.bonsainut.com/threads/in-memoriam-for-those-trees-we-lost-in-2014.18178/#post-244962
Click to expand...
I've got a 14x10x4 training pot...should I use that?
 
I'd put it into something like a 14" or 16" round plastic color pot. Rake back the soil until you see the nebari and remove any roots above that. That semi-large root on the right might be way above the good nebari. There's nothing wrong with doing a hard prune while it's in the ground, but this is a great time of year to pot it up and it'll do just fine. You can take it off a few bits at a time, or you can hard prune the hell out of it, and you'll be fine either way, but if you prune a branch down below the last bit of foliage, and you leave plenty of other foliage growing elsewhere, you'll probably lose that branch. In other words, leave some foliage below each cut, unless you're taking all the foliage off like Larry does in the video Colin posted, otherwise the branches with foliage left will take off, and the ones without foliage will wither away. These guys will backbud like crazy if you prune them really hard this time of year.
 
readc said:
I've got a 14x10x4 training pot...should I use that?
Click to expand...

IMO....

You either want to have a few box sizes, or just put it straight back in the ground.

I sure wouldn't hack the shit out of it to somehow get it in a predetermined pot size.

That Larry seems quite studied in the subject.

I been diggin at a tiny box all day....

I'm positive this...
michaelj said:
semi-large root on the right might be way above the good nebari.
Click to expand...

Is absolutely true....
You can see the taper continue down.

And if the roots you find lower are in any proportion to the ones I'm finding....

I highly doubt a 16" pot will be big enough.

Rule number one.....

Is still....


Be prepared!

Sorce
 
michaelj said:
I'd put it into something like a 14" or 16" round plastic color pot. Rake back the soil until you see the nebari and remove any roots above that. That semi-large root on the right might be way above the good nebari. There's nothing wrong with doing a hard prune while it's in the ground, but this is a great time of year to pot it up and it'll do just fine. You can take it off a few bits at a time, or you can hard prune the hell out of it, and you'll be fine either way, but if you prune a branch down below the last bit of foliage, and you leave plenty of other foliage growing elsewhere, you'll probably lose that branch. In other words, leave some foliage below each cut, unless you're taking all the foliage off like Larry does in the video Colin posted, otherwise the branches with foliage left will take off, and the ones without foliage will wither away. These guys will backbud like crazy if you prune them really hard this time of year.
Click to expand...
Like your standard garden pot from a garden center?
 
readc said:
I have wood, so maybe I'll just make a 16 x 16" box 6" deep.
Click to expand...
That's better but I'd still have a Plan B. You just don't know what's going to come out of the ground and it's much better to over pot and make corrections next year than to under pot and have the tree struggle or die. I'm talking about a 15 gallon nursery pot.
 
Vin said:
That's better but I'd still have a Plan B. You just don't know what's going to come out of the ground and it's much better to over pot and make corrections next year than to under pot and have the tree struggle or die. I'm talking about a 15 gallon nursery pot.
Click to expand...
oooh, I was thinking by something earlier you had said that I need something shallow to start to develop the root reduction process. So, I was thinking I need something more shallow. I can absolutely plant this thing in a standard grow pot those are cheap.

So, I'll have a grow pot on hand (I am assuming this is in case the nebari is much deeper than expected) and I will also make this 16x16x6" box. If the good nebari is shallow, I can use the the box, if it is much deeper I'll use the pot. Is this correct?

PS. wanted to thank you and other for help and suggestions. I have hardly any supplies on hand, so I want to make sure I get everything I need before I dig.
 
readc said:
oooh, I was thinking by something earlier you had said that I need something shallow to start to develop the root reduction process. So, I was thinking I need something more shallow. I can absolutely plant this thing in a standard grow pot those are cheap.

So, I'll have a grow pot on hand (I am assuming this is in case the nebari is much deeper than expected) and I will also make this 16x16x6" box. If the good nebari is shallow, I can use the the box, if it is much deeper I'll use the pot. Is this correct?
Click to expand...
That is all correct and perfectly explained. I don't believe I said anything earlier about about needing something shallow but if I did I apologize.
 
Vin said:
That is all correct and perfectly explained. I don't believe I said anything earlier about about needing something shallow but if I did I apologize.
Click to expand...
no you didn't, my misinterpretation. will post back when she's out of the ground!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

J
American Beech should I dig this up?
2
Replies
22
Views
1K
JohnnyUtah
J
HamburgerTrain
Another, “should i dig this up?” thread (noob)
Replies
8
Views
999
Shibui
S
HamburgerTrain
Should I go dig this free maple?
2
Replies
20
Views
2K
Ohmy222
Ohmy222
Iowa newbie
Should I dig this up?
Replies
6
Views
711
Forsoothe!
Forsoothe!
James W.
Monster DAS, should I dig?
2 3
Replies
45
Views
4K
James W.
James W.
Back
Top Bottom