Is this trident worth it?

Messages
132
Reaction score
108
Location
Lancashire, UK
USDA Zone
9a
So, after an overfertilisation incident, I think I’ve lost my two seedlings, and my two junipers may eventually succumb as well (but hoping they pull through). My birch is clinging on (it avoided the fert incident but not the heatwave and bad watering) and my kataura/candyfloss tree is droopy (again, avoided the fert, but not bad watering and heatwave) and probably isn’t brilliant material anyway.

I’m now looking at getting a new, slightly more developed piece of material that may have some potential. Specifically looking at this trident maple.

IMG_2423.jpegIMG_2424.jpegIMG_2425.jpegIMG_2426.jpeg

These are the only site images. It would cost me around £98/$130/€113 (rounding roughly here) inc delivery.

There are a couple others listed. One has a rather straight trunk and what to me look like quite a knobbly section of pruning scars (here), another has what looks like a section of pancake nebari just on one side and not much else (here), another doesn’t have much movement and to me seems to be planted too high in the pot (here), another looks to have a big region of inverse taper (here). So I’ve narrowed it down to this one, the movement is there and close to the base, I don’t see any glaring root issues so presume a radial nebari should be feasible to work on (apparently tridents/maples are very tolerant of rootwork, do that sounds good)

However this would be my most expensive piece of material, and I’m a bit apprehensive. I’ll admit don’t know what makes a good bit of material. I initially dismissed these until another member said they didn’t look that bad and showed me a £60 straight trunk much thinner than this from elsewhere, so I realised that in comparison this may actually be decent value for a trident here?

Apparently tridents are a bit easier to keep here in the UK compared to Japanese maples. I have no experience with either.

Would plan to be repot in Spring into a larger container, not sure what substrate this is in but this is the place that sells a very popular mix here in the UK but hard to tell if thats what may be under the surface. Either way, it’ll not stay in that pot long. Then eventually trunk chop as that top section is far too straight (do I need a branch in place to become a new leader when the time comes or can I just hope it backbuds?). Not sure how thick it is currently or how thick I’d want it to become. Also no idea how the pruning sites will change over time, will they get lost in the tree as it grows or will it always have bumps here and there?

Would love people's thoughts. Obviously it’ll need a lot of development but is it enough of a solid foundation do we think? Appreciate the insight our experienced members can provide.
 
KLaizen bonsai has been around for a long time. Their substrate can be trusted afaik.

I do not kow why trident would be better than Japanese mpaple to be honest..

Trident is rare in european gardencentres for some reason, so you mostly are confined to bonsai trade. That being said, just recently I saw regular nursery stock sold for 8 euro for a 2 year old tree. So these seem to be OK for the price asked. Not amazing though. For comparison, take a look at bonsai plaza in the Netherlands. They have tridents in all sizes and prices. Been holding off on getting tempted to buy one of theyr root over rock rough stock, just to do a development video. But I have good root over rock tridents myself, and too many trees. [need to keep repeating that mantra!].

1753963747797.png

If you go ahead with your purchase (and the others on the website do not offer a better deal I think), please keep in mind you would probably have to drop the top down, make a new cut. Right now you havea bit of an awkward straight section on a nicely curved lower trunk. The nebari you will need to study. I would probably remove a few roots that sit seemingly in a very low bend on the trunk, but as said.. You need to have the tree in front of you to decide.

In the end, it is in line with regular prices, trader is as far as I have experience -when GB was EEA- reliable. If you want a trident and you can afford it it is not a rubbish buy. Also not a steal, mind you.
Have you tried visiting a social media auction/for slae group based in the UK and put up a want to buy?

Do reach out to @BobbyLane too, as I know he develops a lot of trees and sells them on. He may be able to give you guidance to alternative sources that are viable in the UK. I know he also has purchased from Kaizen and give you pointers/experiences too.
 
Thank you for your insight, Jelle.

I was told tridents grow faster (in general, I imagine) and are ‘more forgiving’ in my climate (which is likely not too dissimilar to yours). So I assume they are less temperamental/more tolerant of the general conditions and the changes in said conditions. Suppose I can’t go wrong either way, JM or Trident.

Had a look at Bonsai Plaza and nothing caught my eye, at least in a price range that felt comfortable at this stage. But good to compare pricing-wise.

Glad you said that the others don’t necessarily offer any better value.

I wasn’t necessarily looking for anything specific, just seeing what was available and I know maples are a classic, seemingly for good reason, been reading threads on here where branches or roots have been thread grafted in, the leaves are nice and small too.

I had a look on a UK buy and sell bonsai facebook page, a suprising amount of nice sized material in the 100-150 range but thats a bit more than I’m comfortable spending at this stage in my journey and again nothing really caught my eye in a way that felt worthwhile pushing the budget, but will keep it in mind in future for sure.
 
Trident grows to be a large tree so just a bit too big for small gardens. Therefore little demand from general gardeners so not stocked by most urban nurseries.
JM is smaller and has a reputation for good colour so is popular even in small gardens and therefore stocked by most nurseries.

Trident is much better for beginner bonsai. Trident is hardier = less likely to die. Trident grows and develops much faster than JM. Trident responds to pruning much better than JM. Trident ramifies much better than JM. JM produces bunches of new shoots which can quickly thicken ends of branches or trunks unless you know and deal with the problem. If you have some problem or need to reduce size, trident responds to hard chop much better than JM.

Assuming the cup is standard size that tree would probably be close to what I would ask for similar. Branches a bit further apart would be nice but not a deal breaker.
Definitely needs some growth to try to even out the taper from lower trunk to new apex but you've already identified that and have plans to try to rectify.
 
Thanks Shibui!

Sounds like I can’t really go wrong then. I bought it last night, won’t ship till middle of next week. From what I’m hearing these are pretty hard to come by in the UK and it’ll be wise for me to airlayer instead of plain trunk chop and propagate anything else I cut off when it gets to the point of being able to remove branches and shoots and whatnot, so may be able to get a couple trees out of it eventually.

Great to hear the advantages of trident over JM. Looking forward to this tree even more now.
 
Nah, this one is worth it though. If you dont buy it within 2 hours I may just go ahead and buy it myself !!

Pros:

Good solid trunk with taper, and muscle. Some movement all the way through to the apex.

Cons: Rootflare will need work, maybe even a ground layer.

2 HOURS THE CLOCK IS TICKING⏳:)
 
My 2 cents of advise: don't buy online, but get in touch with a local bonsai club where you can access better developed starting material for that price range.
It's less convenient and you might have to restrain your eagerness to "go get", but I guarantee that you will take a giant leap forward and a rewarding head start.
i.e. I collected an Acer palmatum Aureum (prolly a Summer Gold) for 35 "quit" 2 days ago. This is its original state.

A_p_Aureum_SummerGold_IMG_5341.jpg
 
Last edited:
Dont let anyone deter you from buying online. I have bought many decent trees online and especially kaizen bonsai among others.
Probably as much as ive bought decent trees in person doing the groundwork.
 
This Beech was £45 on ebay most recently.
How it looked verses after repotting.
Cant beat that for value!

Takes time to hone your eye tho.
 

Attachments

  • 20250411_182939.jpg
    20250411_182939.jpg
    333.6 KB · Views: 53
  • 20250411_133140.jpg
    20250411_133140.jpg
    296.4 KB · Views: 58
Buying online requires a little more scrutiny thats all. There is a bit of a gamble of course, just makes it a bit more fun. Looking at this with a fine tooth comb, as you do when buying online. Zooming in, those roots lined in Red would need to come off, but there is something that can be built on from those White lines, those roots are good. I would make a bet that there is more decent rootage on the right hand side to work from and improve over time. So, the ground layer might not even be needed.

P1270313 7.png


From this angle there is potential to tilt towards the left. Rootage is strong on the right. Maybe a leaning Trident.
P1270317 (1).webp
 
Last edited:
Ah, thanks for everyones responces. It's a shame I can’t edit the first post because I ended up buying the one I showed (which I did also mention in an early reply on rhis thread haha).

The one you like Bobby, I feel the movement is a bit too high? Plus it looks fo have a wiees chunk of inverse taper? I agree is probably a beefier trunk, it was also more expensive and I was already anxious about the price of this one.

This one, at least to me, has nice movement and its low down close to the soil line. I plan on air layering off the top later down the line to get another tree out of it, maybe 3, not sure yet, which will also improve the taper and get rid of the straight section at the same time.

IMG_2481.jpeg

I’m very happy with it, and that's the important thing. I took the layer of weeds/moss off the top and covered the top with a layer of leftover kaizen just so there weren’t any exposed roots. It’ll be repotted into a bigger pot in spring with kaizen then I can also sort the roots.
 
This Beech was £45 on ebay most recently.
How it looked verses after repotting.
Cant beat that for value!

Takes time to hone your eye tho.
now you can sell for 100 ;)... easy peasy...

great beech by the way... mine are looking like branches of yours...
 
Ah, thanks for everyones responces. It's a shame I can’t edit the first post because I ended up buying the one I showed (which I did also mention in an early reply on rhis thread haha).

The one you like Bobby, I feel the movement is a bit too high? Plus it looks fo have a wiees chunk of inverse taper? I agree is probably a beefier trunk, it was also more expensive and I was already anxious about the price of this one.

This one, at least to me, has nice movement and its low down close to the soil line. I plan on air layering off the top later down the line to get another tree out of it, maybe 3, not sure yet, which will also improve the taper and get rid of the straight section at the same time.

View attachment 610099

I’m very happy with it, and that's the important thing. I took the layer of weeds/moss off the top and covered the top with a layer of leftover kaizen just so there weren’t any exposed roots. It’ll be repotted into a bigger pot in spring with kaizen then I can also sort the roots.
Ok cool! I think this one is also suited to a lean towards left.
 
Trident maple will be about the strongest thing you can grow in your bonsai garden. I will put up with flaws with trident maple as long as the nebari and trunk line are decent - because they develop so fast.

I was surprised that they actually sell them at landscape nurseries here - and I've seen a few large ones in peoples' yards.
 
Trident maple will be about the strongest thing you can grow in your bonsai garden. I will put up with flaws with trident maple as long as the nebari and trunk line are decent - because they develop so fast.

I was surprised that they actually sell them at landscape nurseries here - and I've seen a few large ones in peoples' yards.
My municipality has one as a street tree around the corner from me. I was drinking a bloody Mary at a block party when I noticed it.
 
My municipality has one as a street tree around the corner from me. I was drinking a bloody Mary at a block party when I noticed it.
The best trident maple is one viewed with a Bloody Mary in your hand :)

I have 21 two-year-old seedlings that grew from a couple of inches to over 3' - just this year - in 1 gallon pots. 2nd year trees that are 3' tall. Try that with Japanese maple :)
 
Last edited:
Looks like a nice acquisition to me! I’d be happy with that.

Lots of potential directions for styling; just my opinion I would probably try to get the trunk line off vertical with an angle change at the next repot and look at either making cuttings next summer for root grafting the subsequent year during repotting season or acquiring some trident whips for root grafting in the coming repotting season. Although based on your intended angle maybe you can find a position for the tree that keeps the area without many roots in the back.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_7890.jpeg
    IMG_7890.jpeg
    294.3 KB · Views: 21
This Beech was £45 on ebay most recently.
How it looked verses after repotting.
Cant beat that for value!

Takes time to hone your eye tho.
Why there is a small stud lefter on that root in the lower trunk? You tilted the tree as well is it less angel. Sorry just learning about design for deciduous tree. Any thoughts would be great.
 
Why there is a small stud lefter on that root in the lower trunk? You tilted the tree as well is it less angel. Sorry just learning about design for deciduous tree. Any thoughts would be great.
Yes its where a root was cut back, the high root can be seen in one of the pics. Removed because a high root would look ugly on this tree. Yes I preferred the tree at a slight different angle, which highlights its subtle taper and sinuous trunk line.
 
Back
Top Bottom