Azz
Seedling
Yea, after seeing your posts I was planning to cut everything off for the hard prune. Not 100% sure yet to where but somewhere around the marked lines.@Azz if I had to guess I'd say the water being too Alkaline might have been the primary issue. I have all my plants that aren't in their nursery stock containers in training pots with Kanuma with a bit of Yamagoke (moss) interspersed at the root level and used as a top dressing. From your pictures it looks like your plants are pretty leggy, can you give us a side profile of the trunk? What substrate are they sitting in?
My Northern Hi-Lights was pretty leggy, but after repotted it in Kanuma and hard pruned it back to just the primary branch the new growth that grew in was shorter in internode length. From there I think the key is to keep an eye on the "eye spots" because those will be where the new growth with sprout from, and as your plant grows out you prune back to allow growth from those eyes that are positioned where you would like growth to be.
But let me warn you, by "hard prune" I mean you take off all foliage, if you spare any, I've seen where the plant won't kick out nearly as much new growth lower down the plant, it will merely try to get by with what it presently has.
So before you make any big moves on your plant, I'd caution you to make some decisions on your goals for the plant and how happy are you with where it is at. If you want a larger trunk, you are better growing it out for a while and utilizing techniques to encourage trunk development. If you are happy with where the trunk is, and if you have a good primary branch, then go ahead and start the hard prune and refinement techniques. (Which is why I was asking to see the side profile of the trunk)
Keep us posted!
It isn't a very thick or very expensive bit of material. I mainly got it cause it was cheap, a species I have never used before and in an effort to see how well I do keeping it alive over winter as I am not from a cold nation and the last few years my bonsai learning journey has been about that. I also don't mind letting it re-grow to where I can control the growth. So my goals are mainly to cut it back to where I like how it looks and to regrow it, maybe keep it as a smaller tree as it seems the leaves on mine are really small compared to others I have seen (maybe I am being duped by pictures), 3-4cm and very thin have been the biggest I have seen so far (I have also fertilized it heavily) and they seem to be hardening off and not growing anymore.
As for soil, just the standard nursery mix I am guessing. I only got it about a month ago and have been waiting for it to flower before doing the cut.