I like it just fine. I have no plans. Don’t guild the lily. But thanks for your observation as it keeps everyone thinking.@ABCarve Nice tree!
Only thing i noticed is the right trunk it goes straight up and makes a straight right turn in 90° as well that entire branch is fairly straight, you probably already know and there probably isnt a short term fix, what are your toughts about it?
Post#43 kinda says it. The only thing missing is waiting for a flowering spur to develop and that’s where you are at the will of the hawthorn gods (ask @Brian Van Fleet ). What you explained to me in your DM about your pruning methods sounds pretty reasonable. The tree is now at a point where I have to prune off flowering spurs in order to keep the silhouette chased back.OH boy am I enjoying your thread!! All the talk about the shape or pot but really what I find most important is in getting this tree to flower and fruit and how is the pruning incorparated to encourage this!! Please tell us after your 2 year of letting it grow unchecked how you are doing the pruning to keep it flowering ?

I prune for the aesthetics of the tree in general. Can’t control the flowering part so the winter silhouette is the guide. Back-budding is always an issue for keeping the silhouette chased back.Beautiful tree and progression. Do you still practice hedge-pruning/indiscriminate pruning on this tree for ramifiation purposes or do you just focus on setting up the flowering spurs?
Agree. Love the tree. Love the pot. But I don't like the pairing here.Very, very nice !
Would be much, much nicer in another pot...![]()
![]()

Awesome tree. Count yourself lucky if your tree is flowering. All my Crataegus were producing fruit when I collected them, yet they show no sign of flowering for me.This is a hawthorn I collected from a cow pasture around 1997. The past three years I've been chasing it back, mostly from my lack of attention. The mounded soil/moss in the winter pic is me trying to ground layer some roots to the front and back to add to the large lateral roots and even out the nebari. Not sure how well it worked....I'm kind of shy poking around in there. There seems to be roots but what there is seems to be small and tender. I'm getting ready to repot next spring into something smaller.
It finally started flowering again in 2006. I let it fully flower and fruit a couple of years (very cool) but was told that saps a lot of strength from tree. Question... Does it? I've been either cutting them completely off after flowering or just leaving a few as I did this year. Should this be treated like an azalea.....only letting it flowering every second or third year?
Since I started working on the tree again I was letting shoots extend six node and cutting back to 1 or 2 all season. This was the first year I used the hedge method ala Walter P. I'm very happy with the results so far and I know the tree is. Question.... Is there a rule about where flower buds will emerge given the new pruning regime? I really haven't kept track of that.
Mine took 12 years to recover from collection. Patience grasshopperAwesome tree. Count yourself lucky if your tree is flowering. All my Crataegus were producing fruit when I collected them, yet they show no sign of flowering for me.
I have to wait until my 80's. WahhhhMine took 12 years to recover from collection. Patience grasshopperAlthough some never flower. I would enjoy this tree if it didn't flower.