The tree has grown thick and dense. I’ve found that a number of problems start occurring at this level of refinement. The outer canopy gets very dense, shading out light from the interior. As a result, the inner shoots start to yellow and die. The density of leaves on the apex and upper branches shade the lower branches. On apically dominant trees, this is problematic because the apex is stronger anyway. All of this has to be brought back into balance to maintain the health and the shape of the tree. Lengthening shoots can get overly strong too, thickening to the point where they grow out of proportion.
On Japanese Black Pine, we all know the drill - the tools we have to control growth and balance energy by controlling fertilization, decandling and selective needle removal. But how do you do it on broadleaf hardwoods? The same way, more or less, but instead of decandling and pulling needles we use pruning and selective leaf removal. Remember that these are refinement techniques - developing trees is different.
Should we remove all the leaves? I almost never do unless I’m getting ready for a show. Injudiciously removing all the leaves wastes one of the best tools you have for balancing energy. Instead, remove all of the leaves from the strongest growth and leave a more on the weaker growth. Leave more leave on the lower branches and fewer on the upper branches and apex. This is called “partial outer canopy defoliation”. It is used to weaken the strong growth and strengthen the weak growth as well as allow light and air to penetrate the outer canopy to keep the interior shoots healthy.
S