At what temperature do you do the bonsai shuffle

I thought my garage would be enough!!!
Buttonwood are notorious for decline and death in Northern states where they have to spend winters indoors where light and humidity are minimal. They require extreme heat and humidity, as in Florida coastal full sun heat, light and humidity. Unless you have a hothouse you can keep them in for the winter (And most of the spring), and you live further North than Florida, you've going to have issues. Temps lower than 50 are a problem.
 
That was what did it in then. We had a few weeks of less than 50* in the garage. Had plenty of humidity and light, just not warm enough...
 
I would leave them out, my cut off temp is 28 deg for cold hardy trees but wind is also a factor. Sometimes moving them in and out can do more harm then good.
Also the length of the cold period around freezing and below is a big factor, if it's only a couple hours it's usually not a problem.
 
Buttonwood are notorious for decline and death in Northern states where they have to spend winters indoors where light and humidity are minimal. They require extreme heat and humidity, as in Florida coastal full sun heat, light and humidity. Unless you have a hothouse you can keep them in for the winter (And most of the spring), and you live further North than Florida, you've going to have issues. Temps lower than 50 are a problem.

That has not been my experience at all. I’ve had this buttonwood for 4 or 5 years now and it is as healthy as ever, keeping it indoors over winter.

77E6E20C-51F8-4165-A906-A5C0693F0981.jpeg

You just can’t let them get below 50F. This is well known. You also can’t let them dry out.
 
Like I said, we had over a week of less than 50* and that probably did it. Thanks all for the input.

I'll stick to conifers!
 
That has not been my experience at all. I’ve had this buttonwood for 4 or 5 years now and it is as healthy as ever, keeping it indoors over winter.

View attachment 531933

You just can’t let them get below 50F. This is well known. You also can’t let them dry out.


The number of dead buttonwood above the Mason Dixon line has become pretty large over the years since this species became noted for bonsai. People who get them sometimes think they can treat them like ficus or subtropical species. They're touchier than your average Schefflera or pomegranate. FWIW, the "above 50, no dry out" stuff is not well known for the most part, as illustrated in this post.
 
I had no clue from Wiegerts when I bought it...:(

1709666691008.png

Mine used to look this nice...:(
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom