I think the sometimes lack of quality bonsai in the US are due to many factors. First, many people are not that passionate about it..plain and simple. They will have a few trees, but sometimes not even try to learn more. Many are happy with maintaining a beginners amount of knowledge.
Second, money. Bonsai material seems to be getting more and more expensive in the US, as is everything else. Also, taking a micro view, depending where you are in the US, the price can be quite a bit higher. In japan, they can purchase beautiful pre bonsai material sometimes for around $300. When some places in the US would charge like $1000.
Third, attitude. Seems like more and more people seem to think they have mastered the art in a very short time. They dispute the teaching of people that have almost a life time of bonsai experience when they are only just beginniners. This, right out of the gate mentality can lead to a bonsai education that will never really develop. There is the ever present line of thinking, I want to do my own thing and I am going to do it. Doing your own thing at 20-30 years of bonsai experience is great. Doing your own thing at 1 years experience, is just not rational and leads to an huge obstacle in learning that ironically, the person has put there themselves.
Think of it like this. Look at the artists that have well respected work here in the US...How about we Use Ryan Neil since he is pretty well known. As far a I know. He interned with Kimoura in Japan for about 5 years. Now, do you see what happens when a new, beginner bonsai artist can accomplish when he realizes that he needs to pay attention and that there is so much to learn. His learning was uninhibited because he was open to his teachers lessons. He may have questions, but did not refute, dispute and tell Kimura that he was going to do his own thing. The rewards come back a thousand times over if a new enthusiast is willing to be open to all learning.
When you first enter bonsai. Realizing that you know nothing, is actually your greatest learning tool.
Rob
Oh, come now... this sounds like "Old Man Talk"... Those kids will never
learn... you can't teach them a god-d@$m thing...
First let me say that the Bonsai trees of today are much better here in the
US than they were years ago... There is no comparison, period.
This is not because of "Old-Timers", somehow now, deciding not to do what
what they have been doing for years... on the contrary, it is because of those
same folks that you label as "wanting to do my own thing and I am going to do it".
They are the one's wondering why it takes fifty years to do something and are
instead figuring out "new" ways to accomplish something, in a much shorter
time... instead of butting their head against the wall, with an attitude of, "Well...
it's the way it has always been done, as well as the way I was taught..."
You talk about Kimura, as though he was somehow, part of the establishment
in Japan... On the contrary, He pretty much gave them the finger, his work
was not respected for a very long time... and arround some circles, I would
say it is still safe to say he is still not. He broke down barriers, and did things
that were not done in the Bonsai community.
Sorry, but with all due respect your whole post is bull...