To bury or not to bury?

Clicio

Masterpiece
Messages
3,020
Reaction score
8,402
Location
São Paulo, Brazil
USDA Zone
11a
I have this Ume with a twisted lower trunk which I don't like.
If I bury part of this trunk to hide it will it be bad for the health of the tree?

20190216_115802-1422x1954.jpg
20190216_115834-1422x2098.jpg
 
There is too much there to bury but you might be able to do it over several years. Layering as said is a good option, but if you don't like the tree why not sell it and get another.
 
If you like the top, maybe consider layering it off and getting 2 trees.
Thanks, @Stan Kengai
I hadn't considered air layering, it is really a possibility. But the ugly twist would still be there.
I see Prunus Mume as an elegant tree, not a chunky one, and the upper part has a very nice flowing movement (not so visible in these pictures). So the idea of hiding the first twist.
 
Thanks, @Stan Kengai
I hadn't considered air layering, it is really a possibility. But the ugly twist would still be there.
I see Prunus Mume as an elegant tree, not a chunky one, and the upper part has a very nice flowing movement (not so visible in these pictures). So the idea of hiding the first twist.
Not if you layered it off above the twist.
 
Thanks but I like the tree, it's just the first twist that bothers me, looks too flashy, too loud.
I admit that I have never had an Ume but I have seen quite a few and it seems to me that they are mostly chunky trees and not what I would call elegant. The flowers are elegant but the trees I have seen and chunky and angular and very masculine. This is just my experience. They are quite something and I will get at least one and probably this year.
 
But that looks to be the most interesting part of the plant. If you like the top, maybe consider layering it off and getting 2 trees.
This comment intrigues me as i have always been told that Ume were almost impossible to air layer. Is this something that you have successfully done or do you know of someone who has? I have a couple of plants that i have considered for air layering but held off due to the advice i have received and the research i have done on the topic.
 
Cheap & easy.
Ficus are not comparable to ume. Air layering is easy on species that respond to that technique. A successful air layer looks like this. It would be a shame if someone ruined a tree following a technique that does not work with a particular species.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0695.JPG
    IMG_0695.JPG
    222.3 KB · Views: 39
I get that the base is not ideal but I don’t mind the twist. The top portion of the tree to me looks like a generic S curve. I don’t see the overall image improving by removing it. Maybe play around with the planting angle? Just my opinion.
-mike
 
I have this Ume with a twisted lower trunk which I don't like.
If I bury part of this trunk to hide it will it be bad for the health of the tree?

View attachment 227555
View attachment 227556
I think burying the lower portion is a good option and if it results in a ground layer occurring over time then that is a win win. If not, and the base thickens considerably, the visual effect may be much more pleasing as well. Ume are notorious for fungal issues if kept in too wet conditions, particularilary in late winter, early spring so monitor the watering carefully during those times and be careful of pruning cuts. I would be tempted to plant in much larger container to promote more rapid root growth and vigor. Perhaps if feasible put it in the ground for a year or two. Cut some small vertical slits in location you would like to see roots. Apply rooting hormone to the slits, then bury to the level desired and make sure that area remains below ground and moist for best results. I would use a medium size particle mix that holds moisture as well as is free draining. Avoid fine particles or materials that compact too easily affecting drainage.
 
The top portion of the tree to me looks like a generic S curve.
Thanks, Mike, but it's not. The trunk goes back and forth while the vertical curves turn sharply twice. Picture lies to us.


Maybe play around with the planting angle?
Yes. I guess I could do that, less stressful for the tree, thanks.
 
I think burying the lower portion is a good option and if it results in a ground layer occurring over time then that is a win win.

Thanks, @River's Edge, very clear and thorough info, I appreciate your help.
That was my first line of thought for this issue. I will take care with the watering.
 
Thanks, @River's Edge, very clear and thorough info, I appreciate your help.
That was my first line of thought for this issue. I will take care with the watering.
Your welcome. Not sure what your climatic conditions are but the other consideration might be copper based prophylactic treatments during extended cooler wet periods. But i am sure that if you have had ume for some time this will be something you are aware of as a concern for most ume. Some of the more vigorous varieties are better than the more temperamental cultivars.
 
Back
Top Bottom