Root size and health

Attmos

Chumono
Messages
630
Reaction score
398
Location
Columbus, Ohio
USDA Zone
6b
I just read "Introductory to Soil Physics". It's really good. I understand now why sifting for same size particles makes a difference, particle density vs. porosity, capillary action, gravitational effects, and more.

What I'm left wondering, though, is how this affects size and type of roots grown.

If smaller grain is used with more exposure to evaporation, maintaining a good AFP and WFP, will it still grow large healthy feeder roots?

From what I've seen and read, It seems to me like the larger the open space between particles, the larger roots grow. Meaning that any kind of fine grained soil, no matter how well managed, won't ever produce the root structure needed for bonsai.

I know (well, I've been told) that top soil sucks. Trees need larger particles. But is that need, to support them in small pots, or to grow nice roots...?

Balance is always necessary, but it seems like some forms of balance are better than others.
 
I just read "Introductory to Soil Physics". It's really good. I understand now why sifting for same size particles makes a difference, particle density vs. porosity, capillary action, gravitational effects, and more.

What I'm left wondering, though, is how this affects size and type of roots grown.

If smaller grain is used with more exposure to evaporation, maintaining a good AFP and WFP, will it still grow large healthy feeder roots?

From what I've seen and read, It seems to me like the larger the open space between particles, the larger roots grow. Meaning that any kind of fine grained soil, no matter how well managed, won't ever produce the root structure needed for bonsai.

I know (well, I've been told) that top soil sucks. Trees need larger particles. But is that need, to support them in small pots, or to grow nice roots...?

Balance is always necessary, but it seems like some forms of balance are better than others.
Without going into specifics (mainly because I can’t or shouldn’t 😬), a larger grained non-organic soil mix will foster the development of a coarser root structure than found with trees grown in a finer/smaller grained non-organic soil mix, but microscopic feeder roots will be abundant in both mixes. Fwiw, larger grained mixes are associated with more rapid growth and are used frequently with trees in development while finer grained soils are used for both smaller trees and very developed trees.
 
Without going into specifics (mainly because I can’t or shouldn’t 😬), a larger grained non-organic soil mix will foster the development of a coarser root structure than found with trees grown in a finer/smaller grained non-organic soil mix, but microscopic feeder roots will be abundant in both mixes. Fwiw, larger grained mixes are associated with more rapid growth and are used frequently with trees in development while finer grained soils are used for both smaller trees and very developed trees.
This is great information and something that I didn’t really understand when I started out.
I wish I would have because I like to grown smaller trees and I did try a coarser mix for a couple of years. It’s perfectly written!
 
Back
Top Bottom