Now this is just ridiculous

Smoke

Ignore-Amus
Messages
11,674
Reaction score
20,827
Location
Fresno, CA
USDA Zone
9
I had planned on putting Ed Zackery ( cork bark elm) into a pot Sunday. After pulling it from the can I seen a tremendous amount of roots. Many of them were far from the trunk and since I did not wish to cut back and lose the feeder root portion, I though it best to plant it out in a colander. Next year will be better for a pot, maybe not so maybe two years , we will see. The bottom was cut back and flattened and the roots folded back into the pot and filled with soil.
DSC_0096.JPG DSC_0097.JPG DSC_0098.JPG

What I had left was a giant coil of roots. The roots had circled the can about five times. I threw this into a water bucket since I was out of time. Many of the smaller roots were reserved for individual root cutting and the large one was left intact. My bride snapped this picture this evening after work of me holding the coil of roots. Looks like a big slinky and was about 5 feet long stretched out.
DSC_0004.JPG

I was able to cut this thing into two pieces since I had some other roots coming off the middle portion. I got a three footer and a two footer. A wrapped each with the appropriate size wire and began bending them into some cool shapes. I bound the two together at the base to keep them from pushing away. I rigged up a center mast in a pot to tie this thing off since these roots are fleshy and weak but will harden off with being exposed to the sun. Hope they bark up at some point.
With a keen interest in the literati form I thought it only wise to make something to play with. Since the roots are backwards as far as taper goes, yes they are larger at the top than at the bottom. As soon as a crown starts to develop this should right itself.

OK, let the daggers fly......

DSC_0009.JPG
 
Cool project....read about doing something similar with quince roots in International Bonsai. Said to wrap 'em around a rock or sphagum or something, pot 'em up and voilà. Doesn't sound like a good look for an elm, but it looks like you've put some nice movement in yours.

P.s. Mr. Hankey sends his regards:D
 
I love your enthusiasm for this wonderful art! You really are an amazing contributor to this site, and I always enjoy reading about your projects. I look forward to seeing how this goes.
Well thank you very much. A post like this makes it all worthwhile. I also look forward to seeing how this goes. My biggest concern is the reverse taper it has since the largest part is the top because that was closest to the trunk of the tree. I will watch how this grows and see if it sends any bulk low. Hopefully it will.
 
Looking forward to the progress of this tree. I think "ridiculous" is the wrong word tho. Maybe "bizarre"?
 
Hi Smoke,
Si Nguyen used to do a lot of projects like this on Chinese elm about 5 -6 years ago. I don't know if he still has very nice elm collection. I wish he could post something here at this time.
Bonhe
 
My critique:

(1) I love it. Hope it is successful!
(2) I think your curves/bends are a little too regular.
(3) Since you are going with a mother/daughter style, I just want to comment about a Ryan Neil video I watched recently. He was talking about a mother/daughter tree and the emotional connection between the two trunks - almost like a real mother and daughter. Looking at your composition, I don't see an "emotional" connection between the two trunks. And no, I'm not being a troll, I actually thought long and hard about what Ryan said. The two trunks need to complement each other. They don't have to mirror each other, but they have to belong to each other as a unit. Right now they feel completely removed from each other - like each trunk is independent of the other trunk.

Fun!
 
Hi Smoke,
Si Nguyen used to do a lot of projects like this on Chinese elm about 5 -6 years ago. I don't know if he still has very nice elm collection. I wish he could post something here at this time.
Bonhe

Yes Si loves these trees. That is why I know how to buy trees Si will love. Exposed roots and literati - they are his weakness :)
 
Al, this will work. I have quite a few Chinese elm literati from roots. They are fun with twisted trunks.
 
My critique:

(1) I love it. Hope it is successful!
(2) I think your curves/bends are a little too regular.
(3) Since you are going with a mother/daughter style, I just want to comment about a Ryan Neil video I watched recently. He was talking about a mother/daughter tree and the emotional connection between the two trunks - almost like a real mother and daughter. Looking at your composition, I don't see an "emotional" connection between the two trunks. And no, I'm not being a troll, I actually thought long and hard about what Ryan said. The two trunks need to complement each other. They don't have to mirror each other, but they have to belong to each other as a unit. Right now they feel completely removed from each other - like each trunk is independent of the other trunk.

Fun!
I think it is premature to think about that relationship now, having been put together for exactly one day. The feeling of the trees will be built with what comes out of the cut ends and not so much with whats here now. The real problem with this view is the two dimensional nature of the photo. You can't see any of the lateral movement in the trees like I do. I agree the daughter look is just two "S" curves put together, but standing in front of it you don't get that feeling at all. The end of the week is all rain for me but I intend to put this on a turntable and GIF it together for the other views.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom