Lessons learned from first season repotting collected/field grown trees

Lars Grimm

Chumono
Messages
837
Reaction score
1,621
Location
Durham, North Carolina
USDA Zone
7
Hi All,

This is my first real season potting up collected and field grown trees. I was able to get some massive American Hornbeams (trunks from 6-10 inches) as well as some large tridents and japanese maples. I thought I would share some of what I have learned with those new to the process. Hopefully there are not too many black pearls, but I have no doubt people will jump in if they disagree with something =). Please note that these tips are only for deciduous and obviously local climates and species will vary.

In no particular order:
1. The most important thing is survival. You can do some basic structural shaping of major branches but don't go nuts as you are going to need to regrow most branches anyway. You want that newly collected tree in a pot as soon as possible and you will have years ahead of you to work on branch structure.
2. Don't be too afraid of aggressive root pruning. I repotted a few trees myself and was so scared of taking off many roots that I left a lot of thicker roots long. Then, I worked with a senior club member who collects a lot of trees and he cut things back almost all the way to the trunk with a chainsaw. In retrospect I am going to have to go back in a couple years and prune some of these roots back even harder again. It is almost better to know if the tree is going to survive up front than do piecemeal heavy insults every couple years.
3. Make sure your final root cuts are very clean and sharp. You want new fine root growth from all of your big cuts and one import factor is ensuring that you have really clean cambial edges. You can use a rough saw but then go over the edges with a sharp tool. I really like using a pull knife used for carving to quickly clean up the edges.
4. Do not move your newly potted trees. Once you have pruned off all the major roots, the tree is very vulnerable. Fine new root growth will happen within 24 hours but if you move the tree even small shifts will damage these tiny roots. Remember, the tree is mostly being held in place by your wire. Put the tree in a place where it can stay protected for the next couple months.
5. You don't need fancy bonsai soil for new trees. Newly collected trees require a lot of soil and you don't need to break the bank getting that perfect mix of fancy Japanese soil. The most important thing is that it is freely draining. I ended up using a bunch of expanded shale (Permatil) from my local hardware store mixed with some sifted reused bonsai soil.
6. Making the perfect sized wooden box is fun but might not be worth the effort. I really enjoy cutting and working lumber to make pretty boxes with handles but if you have a lot of material it might not be worth the effort. Old nursery tubs work great also and won't break the bank.
7. Buds can move from swelling to extending fast! I had a week of vacation so I was able to look at all my trees very closely and I almost missed my window on a couple.
8. Bring a buddy. Having an extra pair of hands and shovels makes all the difference in the world. We were able to dig up a 12 inch hornbeam in 15 minutes without too much effort.
9. Don't bite off more than you can chew. Remember, if you dig it up you need to haul it out. We almost got a little overzealous with a large beech that weighed a ton.

I might add more things if they come to me, but I hope these help some of the newer members.

Lars
 
This wrench I'm gonna throw can be remedied by understanding one thing.

Balance.

Don't just read that....understand it.

1 and 2 are direct contradictions IMO.

More roots increases survival in most every situation.

My biggest problem with most of what I see collected here....Deciduously...

Is crap or no Nebari.

I'm Ok with it....

But there is absolutely no need to cut any of those roots back.

Get em all...keep em all...
Get good top growth...

And ground layer them.

Safer to cinch a big root then to cut it back too IMO.
1 1 1 1 1 survival.

You don't want to get it in a pot as soon as possible, you want to pot it when it is prepared.

Big wrench?

Dodge it with balance.

Always always always balance.

Sorce
 
This wrench I'm gonna throw can be remedied by understanding one thing.

Balance.

Don't just read that....understand it.

1 and 2 are direct contradictions IMO.

More roots increases survival in most every situation.

My biggest problem with most of what I see collected here....Deciduously...

Is crap or no Nebari.

I'm Ok with it....

But there is absolutely no need to cut any of those roots back.

Get em all...keep em all...
Get good top growth...

And ground layer them.

Safer to cinch a big root then to cut it back too IMO.
1 1 1 1 1 survival.

You don't want to get it in a pot as soon as possible, you want to pot it when it is prepared.

Big wrench?

Dodge it with balance.

Always always always balance.

Sorce


I totally appreciate what you mean about balance. I get the sense that balance is something you can only really learn from experience and probably trial and error.
 
I get the sense that balance is something you can only really learn from experience and probably trial and error.

I tend to think that everything can be thought out. Lol. See how I just thought to think it out?

That's to say....
Don't discount what you can already think.

I believe experience is nothing without constant conscious observation.
Also, waiting for it is silly when one can be humble and apply experience which we have in abundant supply here!
(not that YOU don't)

That will help us minimize error, making time for more trials!

Balance is deep to me.

Not just "balancing the top and bottom" BS they teach in "bonsai class".
But life in general, which is completely transferable to Bonsai in every aspect.

A lot of it has to do with our own individual personal goals.

Knowledge of self determination?!

I think to both extremes... < ····· >
Then keep thinking inward >···< >··<
Until there is only >·<

In the end, there aren't even any scales,
Only
·

Only one perfect thought, move, cut, dig, ANYTHING!

Any unsurety means more thinking is in order.
But then we have to overcome the urge to ignore the unsurety. (see Vance Wood article on "good enough")

Which leads us back to knowledge of self, and how determined we are to be excellent.

Sorce
 
When collecting deciduous trunks, go ahead and collect decent sized seedlings too. You might have to keep until spring to know what you got. If sure of ID, you could use them for root grafts immediately or later.

When doing rootwork on trees that can grow from roots, don't toss them. You could do root grafts later or branches with needed matching bark and leaf characteristics.
 
I tend to think that everything can be thought out. Lol. See how I just thought to think it out?

That's to say....
Don't discount what you can already think.

I believe experience is nothing without constant conscious observation.
Also, waiting for it is silly when one can be humble and apply experience which we have in abundant supply here!
(not that YOU don't)

That will help us minimize error, making time for more trials!

Balance is deep to me.

Not just "balancing the top and bottom" BS they teach in "bonsai class".
But life in general, which is completely transferable to Bonsai in every aspect.

A lot of it has to do with our own individual personal goals.

Knowledge of self determination?!

I think to both extremes... < ····· >
Then keep thinking inward >···< >··<
Until there is only >·<

In the end, there aren't even any scales,
Only
·

Only one perfect thought, move, cut, dig, ANYTHING!

Any unsurety means more thinking is in order.
But then we have to overcome the urge to ignore the unsurety. (see Vance Wood article on "good enough")

Which leads us back to knowledge of self, and how determined we are to be excellent.

Sorce
Man, you're getting deep. Did you quit drinking? :)
 
Back
Top Bottom