Dig in the spring or wait a few years?

[Gabler]

This Carpinus caroliniana is finally thick enough for bonsai, but it could always be thicker. Would you dig it this spring and make a chuhin-sized tree or let it get huge? I guess either way, I should dig it up and sort out the roots, but I'm curious what your approach would be.

 

[BobbyLane]

My decision would rest on what the root base is like. It can potentially make a nice tree at the current size, it comes down to what your tastes are currently. I personally like trees in all shapes and sizes.

 

[BrightsideB]

I would dig it. If you want something larger plant it in the garden were you can expedite it’s growth with more sun, water, and fertilizer. Or pass and use time looking for larger material. It has cool movement.

 

[Gabler]

My decision would rest on what the root base is like. It can potentially make a nice tree at the current size, it comes down to what your tastes are currently. I personally like trees in all shapes and sizes.

I would dig it. If you want something larger plant it in the garden were you can expedite it’s growth with more sun, water, and fertilizer. Or pass and use time looking for larger material. It has cool movement.

I'll definitely dig it up this spring either way. I guess if I need to sort out the roots, it makes sense to plant it in the ground on a board or tile and let it grow more, and if the roots are in good shape already, it makes sense to go ahead and put it in a container.

 

[Cajunrider]

I'll definitely dig it up this spring either way. I guess if I need to sort out the roots, it makes sense to plant it in the ground on a board or tile and let it grow more, and if the roots are in good shape already, it makes sense to go ahead and put it in a container.

I dig your decision.

 

[Ininaatigoons]

Emphasize that taper! Let that sacrificial grow and start training that curve. And yes of course you'll want to check roots.

 

[Javaman4373]

I have one much like yours that I am going to dig in the spring.